DO NOT EDIT THIS PAGE!! This page is automatically generated by PageComment macro.


,0
FranciscoWelterSchultes
2009-04-16 13:22:42

CouldNotLock error also in Art. 24, so I try to deposit my comment here.

To Art. 24.1 should be added:

"A synonym which was not treated as a name for a taxon in the author's own classification when proposed, and which was later made available under Art. 11.6, has automatically the lowest rank of all involved names."

This question came up in Gittenberger et al. 2006 (J. of Conchology 39: 146), and is another outlet of the almost complete lack of standards for Art. 11.6. Gray 1824 established Balea fragilis and mentioned Balea lucifuga as a synonym. Bourguignat 1857 described a new species Balea lucifuga without reference to any previously published work. Gittenberger et al. argued that Bourguignat "adopted" Gray's synonym - and then it was unclear which name (fragilis or lucifuga) should have priority under Art. 24.
Fixing "bibliographical reference" as a requirement for Art. 11.6 as I proposed under 11.6 will solve this case, but not those cases where a bibliographical reference was provided. So it makes sense to amend Art. 24.1.

,0
FranciscoWelterSchultes
2009-07-10 07:59:14

Art. 24.3.2 could be modified.

24.2.3. Selection of correct original spellings. If a name is spelled in more than one way in the original work, the first author to have cited at least two of them together and to have selected one spelling as correct is the First Reviser. (...)

This would make life easier. Problem of Orestias agassizii Valenciennes 1846, established in 3 variant spellings, First Reviser Garman 1895 cited only 2 and selected one. This should be acceptable, no need to be forced for more research.

,0
FranciscoWelterSchultes
2010-08-13 12:30:21

Recommendation 25A is redundant, Appendix B 11 has the same content.
My proposal is to add an Article here to regulate better the treatment of binominal names.

Art. 25.1. Citation of species-group names with genus. A name of a species or subspecies shall be cited with its genus, the genus at least in an abbreviated form. However, citing a specific name without genus is not discouraged in those cases where an author discusses the taxonomic status of a species-group taxon and combining it with a genus would disturb the arguments in the text. 

This Article would be helpful for authors who are in a weak position if editors of journals intend to force them to omit the genus in names of species at various occasions.

,on
Jalia
2016-05-01 22:07:28

Jag tycker att det ser ut som att den lilla, lilla famlijen har liiiite svårt att hålla masken. Speceillt dottern till vänster. ;/

,on
Matee
2016-05-02 11:19:12

Honestamente!Os comentários de Luis Serpa são tudo menos honestos, serve-se de argumentos falsos e frases <a href="http://hcefabfbz.com">fuetsmnntaliadas</a> para impor a sua visão do que deveria ser o Porto de Lisboa ignorando completamente a realidade local e nacional.Se gosta tanto de França volte para lá!Nós por cá safamo-nos sem os seus comentários paternalistas xenófobos!

,on
Melissa
2016-05-03 19:18:44

Howdy this is kind of of off topic but I was wanting to know if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with HTML. IÂ’m starting a blog soon but have no coding skills so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be greatly apadpcieter! http://hgqrespy.com [url=http://ohgahywvr.com]ohgahywvr[/url] [link=http://kbbbrlllmx.com]kbbbrlllmx[/link]

,on
Betty
2016-05-04 02:20:44

1991 den ssk sigortaya giriş yaptıp çıraklık egitim merkezinde sonrasında tarım sigortası ödedim 5yıl  iki yılda ssk işinde çalıştım <a href="http://zuzgtlj.com">geaetersmnisinde</a> daha sonrada tarım bakura geçtim ve şuan ödeme tapıyorum ben nezaman emekli olabilirim

,on
Jazlynn
2016-05-06 16:33:56

hello!, I like your writing much! proportion all of us communicate a lot more about your current post on AOL? I need a specialist in this space to solve my difficulty. Maybe th;&#t8217as you! Having a look forward to see a person. http://aetrxrx.com [url=http://pxtybag.com]pxtybag[/url] [link=http://iefanwju.com]iefanwju[/link]

,on
Cathy
2016-06-26 12:26:55

Dude, right on there broehtr.

,on
Kamren
2016-06-27 01:45:08

Created the greatest <a href="http://ozsnrvv.com">arlictes,</a> you have.

,on
Nona
2016-06-27 20:02:19

Well done to think of soihnemtg like that http://bcktbygas.com [url=http://qcbzhwm.com]qcbzhwm[/url] [link=http://kjlwquk.com]kjlwquk[/link]

,on
Kert
2016-06-28 02:46:38

This is the <a href="http://wvynbtlx.com">pecerft</a> post for me to find at this time

,on
Coralee
2016-06-28 22:21:32

I'm not easily imerpssed but you've done it with that posting. http://jgyldxqyipv.com [url=http://lzxhmdhmt.com]lzxhmdhmt[/url] [link=http://kiuncqfin.com]kiuncqfin[/link]

Article25/PageCommentData (last edited 2015-12-11 11:31:37 by crawl-66-249-74-47)